The Legal Dos and Don’ts of Collecting Google Maps Reviews

published on 01 October 2024

Want to boost your business with Google Maps reviews? Here's what you need to know:

  • Google Maps reviews can make or break your online reputation
  • 85% of consumers trust these reviews as much as personal recommendations
  • Positive reviews boost visibility and credibility, but there are strict rules

Key takeaways:

  1. Ask for honest feedback, don't offer rewards
  2. Make it easy for customers to leave reviews
  3. Respond to all reviews professionally
  4. Don't create fake reviews or manipulate ratings
  5. Stay updated on Google's changing policies

Quick comparison of what to do and avoid:

Do Don't
Ask for honest feedback Offer incentives for reviews
Provide clear review instructions Create fake reviews
Respond to all reviews Hide negative feedback
Set up a consistent review system Filter or manipulate reviews

Remember: Breaking Google's rules can result in penalties, lost reviews, or even legal trouble. Stay compliant to maintain trust and improve your online presence.

Google's Review Rules

Google's review system is powerful, but it has strict rules. Here's what you need to know:

Google's Terms of Service

Google's terms are simple: reviews must be real. This means:

  • No fake reviews
  • No paid reviews
  • No review manipulation

Break these rules? You're in trouble. Just ask Fashion Nova. They got slapped with a $4.2 million fine in March 2022 for blocking bad reviews.

Main Review Guidelines

Here's what Google wants for Maps reviews:

Do Don't
Ask for honest feedback Bribe for reviews
Give clear review instructions Make up reviews
Respond to all reviews professionally Hide negative reviews
Keep an eye on your reviews Mess with customer reviews

Google's not messing around: "Reviews should be real. No conflicts of interest."

Why care? 71% of all customer reviews are on Google (Birdeye report). That's a LOT of eyeballs.

Here's the twist: Google lets you ask for reviews (unlike Yelp), but no "review gating." You can't just show the good stuff and hide the bad.

So what CAN you do? Google's got a free Marketing Kit to help you get reviews the right way. Use it.

Break these rules? Google might axe your reviews, suspend your account, or kill your entire Google listing.

Play by the rules, and you'll get the good stuff: real customer feedback.

What You Can Do to Get Reviews

Want more Google Maps reviews? Here's how to do it right:

Ask at the Right Time

Timing is key. Ask when customers are happiest:

  • Just after a purchase
  • When you've fixed an issue
  • After a good interaction

Pro tip: Tell customers early on that you'll ask for feedback later. It primes them to leave a review.

Make It Easy

Customers should be able to leave reviews without hassle:

1. Create a short link to your Google review page

2. Add this link everywhere:

  • Your website
  • Email signatures
  • Receipts
  • Follow-up messages

Here's a real example:

Jeda Logistics added a star rating and Google link to their thank-you page. Result? 19 new Google reviews in 3 months.

Respond to Every Review

Good or bad, answer all reviews. It shows you care.

Do Don't
Thank reviewers Ignore negative feedback
Address concerns Get defensive
Be professional Use cookie-cutter responses

Create a Review System

Set up a consistent way to ask for reviews:

1. Train your team on how to ask

2. Use different methods (email, SMS, in-person)

3. Follow up (but don't be pushy)

Did you know? 86% of customers are willing to write a review. You just need to ask!

What Not to Do When Getting Reviews

Getting Google Maps reviews can boost your business. But there are rules. Here's what to avoid:

Don't Offer Rewards for Reviews

Giving incentives for reviews? Big mistake. It's against Google's rules and can land you in hot water.

In 2015, the FTC went after Amerifreight, a vehicle shipping company. Their crime? Charging customers an extra $50 if they didn't write a review. The FTC wasn't happy.

"Charging customers who don't write you a review is half-pushy, half-stupid, and wholly illegal." - Convince & Convert

Don't Make Fake Reviews

Fake reviews are a no-go. If you're caught:

  • Say goodbye to all your reviews
  • Your Google Business Profile? Suspended
  • Legal trouble? You bet

It's not worth it. Stick to real reviews from real customers.

Don't Filter Reviews

Review gating is out. Google wants the whole picture, warts and all.

In 2018, Google said: don't cherry-pick reviews. By 2022, "fake engagement" was on their naughty list.

Don't Change or Delete Customer Reviews

Bad reviews are here to stay. Only the reviewer can delete them. Trying to change or remove reviews can:

  • Get you in legal trouble
  • Hurt your reputation
  • Make customers lose trust

Instead, respond to ALL reviews professionally. Show you care about feedback, even the bad stuff.

Do Don't
Ask everyone for reviews Bribe for reviews
Respond to all feedback Make up reviews
Provide great service Hide negative reviews
Address concerns openly Mess with reviews

Handling Tricky Situations

Let's tackle two common issues with Google Maps reviews:

Competitor Reviews

Competitors might leave fake negative reviews. Here's what to do:

1. Document everything

Screenshot suspicious reviews. Note dates and usernames. This helps if you need to report or take legal action.

2. Check Google's policies

If the review breaks rules, flag it for removal.

3. Respond professionally

Treat it like a real customer review. Show others you take feedback seriously.

4. Report to Google

Use your Google Business Profile to report fake reviews. Be patient - Google isn't always quick.

5. Legal action (last resort)

In extreme cases, you might need a lawyer.

Employee Reviews

Employee reviews can be tricky:

Do Don't
Ask employees to disclose their relationship Force employees to review
Encourage honest feedback Offer incentives for good reviews
Respond professionally Delete or hide employee reviews

Google wants real reviews. In 2022, they banned "fake engagement".

About 1 in 50 reviews are negative. For law firms, it's often worse. Don't stress - it's normal.

If you spot a fake review, act fast but stay cool. As one business owner said:

"A competitor's bad review feels like a punch to the gut. But it's a chance to show how professional we are and how much we care about our customers."

The key? Respond quickly and professionally to ALL reviews. It shows potential customers you value feedback and want to improve.

sbb-itb-0fc0b25

Rules for Businesses with Many Locations

Managing Google Maps reviews for multi-location businesses isn't easy. Here's how to keep things consistent and follow the rules:

Choose Your Management Model

You've got two main options:

1. Corporate Management

A central team handles all reviews. It keeps your brand voice consistent but might miss local nuances.

2. Individual Location Management

Each location manages its own reviews. It's quick and personal, but can lead to inconsistencies.

Set Up Separate Google Business Profiles

Create a unique Google Business Profile for each location. It helps customers leave reviews in the right place and lets you manage each spot's online presence.

Use the Right Tools

Pick a review management tool that fits. Statusbrew, for example, offers central control while allowing local managers to respond quickly.

Create Guidelines and Templates

Develop clear response guidelines. Include:

  • Brand voice rules
  • Response time goals
  • How to handle common issues

Make templates for typical situations to speed things up and keep responses consistent.

Train Your Team

Whether you're going corporate or individual, train your team on:

  • Google's review policies
  • Your company's guidelines
  • How to use your chosen management tools

Monitor Performance

Keep tabs on how each location is doing. Look for patterns or issues that need addressing.

Metric Why It Matters
Average star rating Shows overall satisfaction
Response rate Shows how active you are
Response time Shows how quick you are

Stay Up-to-Date with Google's Rules

Google's review policies change often. Make sure someone's keeping an eye on these changes.

Use Google's Free Tools

Take advantage of Google's free digital Marketing Kit to encourage reviews across all locations.

Handle Special Cases Carefully

Some situations need extra attention:

Employee Reviews: Ask employees to disclose their relationship when reviewing.

Multiple Services: If you offer different services at one spot, use Google's secondary hours feature to list separate hours for each.

Keeping Up with Rule Changes

Google's review policies are always changing. Here's how to stay in the loop:

  1. Check official sources: Visit Google Business Profile Help Center and Maps User Contributed Content Policy pages monthly.

  2. Set up Google Alerts: Get notified about policy updates with keywords like "Google review policy update".

  3. Follow Google's socials: Keep an eye on their Twitter and LinkedIn for announcements.

  4. Join online communities: Participate in forums like the Google Business Profile Help Community for insights.

  5. Use review management tools: These often alert users to policy changes.

Recent Changes to Watch

Date Change Impact
November 2023 Reviews System update Daily review ranking adjustments
April 2018 Terms of Service update No more review gating
2020 COVID-19 policy addition New rules for COVID-19 mentions

When Google updates its policies:

  1. Review your current practices
  2. Update review request templates
  3. Train your team on new rules
  4. Audit existing reviews for compliance

"The Reviews System is a key element of Google's algorithms that ranks review-centric content and evaluates search queries."

Stay on top of these changes to keep your review strategy effective and compliant.

Wrap-up

Google Maps reviews can make or break a local business. They're crucial for visibility and credibility. But following Google's review policies isn't easy. Here's a quick recap:

Do Don't
Ask for honest feedback Offer rewards for reviews
Give clear steps to leave reviews Create fake reviews
Respond to all reviews quickly Filter out negative reviews
Have a regular review strategy Edit or delete customer reviews

Why follow these rules? Your online reputation and search ranking depend on it. In 2023, businesses got about 66 new Google reviews per location. That's 66 chances to impress—or mess up.

Some key facts:

  • 91% of people trust real online reviews
  • Businesses that respond to reviews seem 1.7 times more trustworthy
  • One bad review can cost you around 30 customers

It's not just numbers. It's about trust. One business owner said:

"We saw a 300% increase in foot traffic after we started managing our Google reviews. It wasn't just about getting more reviews—it was about showing our customers we cared."

Keep up with Google's changing policies. Set up Google Alerts, check the Google Business Profile Help Center often, and join online groups to stay in the loop.

FAQs

What not to do on Google reviews?

When it comes to Google reviews, businesses need to play by the rules. Here's what you should NEVER do:

1. Post fake reviews

Don't even think about creating reviews from imaginary customers. Google's not fooled, and it's a big no-no.

2. Offer incentives

Trying to buy reviews with rewards or cash? That's a quick way to get on Google's bad side.

3. Duplicate content

Copying and pasting the same review multiple times? Google calls that spam. Don't do it.

4. Manipulate ratings

Boosting your own ratings or trashing competitors? That's playing dirty, and Google won't stand for it.

5. Review gating

Cherry-picking only happy customers for reviews? That's unfair and against the rules.

Here's a quick breakdown:

Don't Why
Fake reviews Google hates lies
Incentives Breaks Google's rules
Duplicates It's just spam
Rating manipulation Can get you penalized
Review gating Skews ratings unfairly

Google's take on this is crystal clear:

"Reviews should represent the genuine experience of the user, and should not be written by someone with a conflict of interest." - Google

Related posts

Read more