Common Mistakes to Avoid When Asking for Google Reviews

Google reviews can make or break your business. Here's why they matter and what mistakes to avoid:

• 95% of people read online reviews before buying
• 93% say reviews affect their purchasing decisions
• More reviews can boost your visibility in search results
• A 1-star rating increase can lift revenue by 5-9%

8 key mistakes to avoid:

1. Not asking for reviews
2. Asking at the wrong time
3. Offering rewards (against the rules)
4. Making reviews hard to leave
5. Ignoring negative feedback
6. Using generic copy-paste requests
7. Forgetting to follow up
8. Breaking Google's guidelines

The bottom line: Manage reviews properly to build trust, attract customers, and grow your business. But do it the right way - no shortcuts or tricks.

1. Not Asking for Reviews

Many businesses don't ask for reviews. Big mistake. Here's why:

• 68% of customers will leave a review if asked
• 85% of consumers don't trust reviews older than 3 months
• 93% of customers read reviews before buying

Jack Trent, CPA and owner of JTC CPAs, says:

"Customer reviews are the lifeblood of small businesses, playing a pivotal role in their success."

How to fix this:

1. Ask happy customers for reviews before they leave
2. Follow up with satisfied past customers
3. Give them a direct link to your Google My Business page
4. Ask right after a successful purchase or service

Remember: Not asking = missed opportunities, stale online presence, and limited social proof.

2. Asking at the Wrong Time

Timing is crucial for Google reviews. Ask at the wrong moment, and you'll miss out on valuable feedback.

Why does timing matter? Simple:

• Customers need time to form opinions
• Ask too early, you'll annoy them
• Wait too long, they'll forget details

So when's the right time? It depends:

Take Le Kliff, a remote restaurant. They ask for TripAdvisor reviews right after meals. Smart move.

Martin Shervington, a local reviews expert, says:

"Personal connections boost review likelihood. A server, manager, or owner asking makes a difference."

Want more reviews? Try these:

1. Ask happy customers
2. Use social media
3. Time it right (2-3 PM and 6-7 PM are hot spots)
4. For stores, put requests on receipts or use in-store kiosks

Remember: strike while the iron's hot. Don't let that perfect review moment slip away.

3. Offering Rewards for Reviews

Offering rewards for Google reviews? Don't do it. It's not just wrong - it's against the rules and can land you in hot water.

Why it's a bad move:

• It's illegal. The feds don't play around with this stuff.
• Google says no. Their policies are clear: no rewards for reviews.
• The penalties hurt. Companies have paid big bucks for fake reviews.

Real-world consequences:

California car dealerships coughed up $3.6 million in FTC fines. A Nashville music company? $250,000. Aura Labs got slapped with a $100,000 fine for fake app reviews.

And it's not just cash. Free stuff, discounts, or any perks count as rewards.

So what's the right way?

1. Nail your customer service
2. Ask for reviews at the perfect moment
3. Make it super easy to leave feedback

Genuine reviews trump paid praise every time. They build trust and keep Google happy.

Here's a wake-up call:

A Kentucky law firm tried to game the system with contests for reviews. The result? Google wiped out almost all their reviews overnight. They went from 100 five-stars to just one. Ouch.

The takeaway? Skip the rewards. Earn reviews the right way. Your online rep will thank you.

4. Making Reviews Hard to Leave

Ever tried to solve a Rubik's Cube blindfolded? That's how some customers feel when trying to leave a Google review. Don't do that.

If leaving a review is harder than rocket science, you're doing it wrong. People are busy. They won't jump through hoops to sing your praises.

How to make it easy:

1. Use a direct link: Google lets you create a sharable link that takes customers straight to your review page. No searching, no fuss.

2. Keep it quick: The whole process should take 2-3 minutes, tops.

3. Guide them: Spell out the steps. Like this:

   1. Copy and paste your review below.
   2. Click this link: [Your Google Review Link]
   3. Paste your review, select a rating, and click Done.
   

4. Go mobile: Make sure your review process works smoothly on phones. That's where most people will leave reviews.

Here's the kicker: 76% of consumers will leave a review if asked. But it needs to be dead simple.

"Customers stop caring when it becomes tough to actually write a review – whether that's on your site or a third party site." - Andrew McDermott, Co-founder of HooktoWin

A clunky review process is like having a "Closed" sign on your door when customers want to praise you.

5. Not Responding to Bad Reviews

Ignoring negative reviews? Big mistake. It's like snubbing a customer in your store. Bad for business and a wasted opportunity to show you care.

Why does responding matter? The numbers speak for themselves:

• 93% of people read reviews before buying
• 45% are more likely to shop with businesses that reply to bad reviews
• 53% expect a response within a week

Silence has consequences. One bad review can cost you 30% of potential customers. Three? You could lose up to 59%.

So, what's the game plan?

1. Act fast: Respond within 24 hours
2. Say thanks: Even for negative feedback
3. Own up: Take responsibility
4. Offer solutions: Don't just apologize—fix it
5. Keep it personal: Use names, avoid copy-paste replies

Here's a real-world example:

A NYC psychiatrist got a nasty review in March 2023. Instead of ignoring it, he focused on getting new positive reviews. Within a month, he added 19 glowing testimonials, pushing the bad review down and reducing its impact.

How you handle bad reviews can turn things around. As Max Freedman, a business writer, puts it:

"Responding to reviews allows businesses to address negative reviews, build consumer trust, increase ratings and grow sales."

Don't let bad reviews go unanswered. It's your chance to show you care and potentially win back customers.

sbb-itb-0fc0b25

6. Using Copy-Paste Review Requests

Generic review requests? They're about as exciting as a stale pizza crust. Here's why they fall flat:

• Customers can smell a template a mile away
• It's like saying, "You're just another sale to us"
• Your chances of getting a review? They plummet

The secret sauce? Personalization.

Forget "Dear Valued Customer." Go for "Hey Sarah!" Use their name and mention something specific about their experience:

"Tom! How'd that deep-dish treat you last night? We're dying to know what you thought!"

This approach isn't just fluff. Judge.me found that personalizing review request emails boosted conversion rates by 30%. That's a lot of extra reviews.

But don't stop at names. Tailor your whole message:

Timing is everything. Don't wait a week. Strike while the pizza's still hot - within 24-48 hours of their visit.

And make it easy. Include a direct link to your Google Business Profile. The fewer clicks, the more likely they'll leave a review.

7. Forgetting to Check Back

You've asked for reviews. Great! But don't stop there. Many businesses forget to follow up, missing out on valuable feedback and stronger customer relationships.

Why is checking back so important?

• Recent reviews matter: 85% of consumers don't trust reviews older than 3 months
• It shows you care about customer input
• You can turn negative experiences into positive ones

Here's how to stay on top of it:

1. Set up a system

Use automated workflows to send review invites after customer interactions:

2. Close the loop

Act on feedback. As Kareem Mayan, Co-founder at Savio, says:

"Closing the loop is a relatively simple way to deepen relationships with your customers, increase retention, and even recover lost customers."

3. Schedule regular check-ins

Meet with your team to review feedback and plan actions.

4. Use tools

Set up Google Alerts and review tracking software to stay informed.

5. Respond promptly

Show customers you're listening by addressing their comments quickly.

8. Breaking Google's Rules

Google's review rules are no joke. Break them, and you're in for a world of hurt. Here's the lowdown:

Fake reviews? Big mistake. Google will nuke them and might even kill your business listing. Just ask Fashion Nova - they got slapped with a $4.2 million fine in 2022 for blocking bad reviews.

No bribes for reviews. Even small stuff like free zoo tickets is a no-go. Google will trash those reviews faster than you can say "incentive."

Don't cherry-pick reviewers. Asking only happy customers for feedback? That's called "review gating", and Google hates it.

Watch your words. When asking for reviews, don't hint that you only want the good stuff. Google sees right through that.

Here's your cheat sheet for staying in Google's good graces:

Break these rules, and you're looking at:

• All your reviews vanishing
• Your Google Business Profile getting axed
• Potential FTC fines (up to $43,792 per violation)

Don't mess with Google's review system. It's not worth the risk.

Conclusion

Google reviews can make or break your business. They're not just a nice extra—they're crucial for growth in today's digital world.

Here's why they matter:

• They boost trust
• They help local search rankings
• They sway buying decisions

And get this: 94% of people have avoided a business because of a bad review. That's huge.

So, what should you do? Avoid these mistakes:

1. Not asking for reviews
2. Asking at the wrong time
3. Offering rewards (don't do it)
4. Making reviews hard to leave
5. Ignoring bad feedback
6. Using generic requests
7. Forgetting to follow up
8. Breaking Google's rules

But good review management isn't just about dodging pitfalls. It's about connecting with your customers.

Here's your action plan:

As Jack Trent from JTC CPAs says:

"Customer reviews are the lifeblood of small businesses, playing a pivotal role in their success."

The bottom line? Manage your reviews well, and you'll see results. More trust, more customers, more growth. Simple as that.

FAQs

Is it okay to ask for Google reviews?

Yes, Google's fine with you asking for reviews. They actually want you to do it. But there's a right way:

• Ask right after you've helped a customer
• Keep it short and sweet
• Don't bribe people for reviews
• Show them how to leave a review
• Ask regularly

Here's a quick breakdown:

Fun fact: When you ask for reviews, they tend to be better. InMoment found that requested reviews average 4.34 stars, while spontaneous ones sit at 3.89.

"For small businesses, customer reviews are gold." - Jack Trent, JTC CPAs

Related posts

• Proven Strategies to Boost Your Google Maps Reviews Fast
• Maximize Your Google Maps Presence: How to Get More Reviews
• The Ultimate Guide to Getting More Google Reviews for Your Business
• Top 10 Tips for Increasing Google Maps Reviews Effectively